Construction contract law case studies

Eighteen months into the project, the principal expressed concern regarding what it said was the slow progress, poor quality of the Construction contract law case studies and the quantum of progress claims submitted by the contractor.

The underlying litigation stemmed from mold damage, originating from the defective trusses, and spreading to other, non-defective, components of the buildings. Trial was completed in April and a favorable decision was received that August that awarded full damages.

Balfour Beatty argued that the terms of the subcontract had been sufficiently finalised so that there was an arbitration agreement between the parties.

However to avoid the unintended consequences of this case, we recommend that parties following these two basic rules: The mere existence of acceleration in performance is insufficient to establish that the other party acted to induce the acceleration, and absent evidence to the contrary, the acceleration is presumed to be a voluntary action.

The Court, after hearing oral argument, granted our motion for temporary restraining order and, after an evidentiary hearing lasting several days, granted our motion for preliminary injunction, which then led to a favorable settlement for our client. Pass-Through Claims On complex construction projects, subcontractors occasionally incur damages directly attributable to a breach by the owner of its contract with a prime contractor.


Under the contract, the show cause notices must among other things specify the alleged substantial breach. Thus, only in rare cases where legal damages fail to adequately or effectively remedy the harm caused by the breach may the court impose a remedy of specific performance.

As with any damage award, damages for breach of a construction contract must be supported by probative evidence and cannot be based on mere speculation, conjecture, or surmise. The contract provided for sectional completion and contained typical provisions for liquidated damages for delay and extensions of time on the occurrence of a "relevant event".

To view all formatting for this article eg, tables, footnotesplease access the original here. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio was settled on favorable terms for our client.

Top 5 construction cases 2012

In this case, the plaintiff had put up a property for sale at auction, subject to a reserve. Detailed particulars are not necessarily required for a valid show cause notice. Employing creative contracting techniques, including Quick Pay, allowed the school to open an entire school year early, on budget and with no construction claims or disputes.

Consideration in this form is required for a contract to be legally binding. As defects arose the original contractor began court proceedings alleging that the new contractor was responsible for the defects under the business sale agreement.

It is important to emphasize that excusable delay clauses do not shift the burden of the losses incurred by such a delay to the other party. After the tenants association subsequently voted not to enter into the assignment agreement that we negotiated, we filed suit on behalf of our client against the tenants association, alleging that the tenants association breached its contractual obligation under the letter of intent to in good faith negotiate and enter into the assignment agreement, and seeking specific performance of that obligation, as well as a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction enjoining the tenants association from assigning its TOPA rights to purchase the apartment complex to any other party.

This aim is consistent with free-market economic theory. Where the business is shown to have been already established and making a profit at the time when the contract was breached or the tort committed, such pre-existing profit, together with other facts and circumstances, may indicate with reasonable certainty the amount of profits lost.

If you require expert assistance from a contract lawyer Melbournecontact LGM Advisors on 03 or by email at marketing lgmadvisors. Lost profits resulting from a breach of contract are well-recognized as being recoverable so long as they are established to a reasonable degree of certainty.

A constructive acceleration claim differs from constructive acceleration orders discussed above, which may be imposed to trigger an actual claim. Facts The case concerned the construction of an apartment block in Richmond, Melbourne.

Loss in value, also known as direct damages, are all those losses sanctioned by the first branch of the Hadley test which arise naturally from a breach of contract. Introduction There were many noteworthy cases handed down inhowever we focused on those which have the most interest and practical relevance to our clients.

This case has application in other jurisdictions including New South Wales and Victoria given the similarly worded Security of Payment Acts in those states. No damage is sustained beyond the building itself. That conclusion was only reached because the progress certificate was deemed to no longer operate as a precondition after a point in time.

However, as with any breach of contract action, the contractor has a duty to mitigate damages and must take other work, if able, to minimize the potential damages caused by a construction delay.

This landmark case with statewide ramifications was not only a victory for our client, but is now the law on liquidated damages in Ohio, determining the enforceability of liquidated damages clauses in the state and being the subject of many amicus briefs and public interest.

Top three construction cases: June 2016

The principal engaged the contractor under an AS — Construct only form of contract. In Victoria, courts are unlikely to imply a term of reasonableness when issuing a show cause notice or evaluating whether cause has been shown.

Ball park figures are insufficient. In rare cases, where a non-breaching party will enjoy the benefit of the bargain only where a defective structure is totally rebuilt, costs to rebuild rather than repair may be a reasonable measure of damages.

Facts This case arose out of a joint venture agreement between Lesdor Properties Pty Ltd Lesdorthe owner of a property, and Cordon Investments Pty Ltd Cordona property developer and commercial builder.

In certain circumstances, home office overhead can be recovered when properly Construction contract law case studies to a specific construction project. Lastly, it must be emphasized that it is a well-settled legal principle that efforts to induce performance of the contract by the original target date do not give rise to an acceleration claim when the cause of the delay is solely the actions of the performing party.

However, a more thoroughgoing analysis, as presented in two recent Federal Circuit opinions-Stanley Martin Companies, Inc. Finding The Court found for Wambo and required Downer to comply with the dispute resolution provisions before continuing with the court proceedings. When legal damages are insufficient to genuinely remedy the injury caused by the breach, specific performance is a possible, but extremely rare, remedy.

Delays in completion of construction projects may result in various consequential damages that are not amenable to proof.Top 5 construction cases The case concerned the construction of an apartment block in Richmond, Melbourne. A clause in a contract, which had the effect of prohibiting the service of a.

Case Studies FEATURED Community Centre, Foxton, New Zealand Completed in Novemberthe NEC-procured project won the NEC Project of the Year Award in.

In a case that wound through the courts and was decided by the Ohio Supreme Court, Kegler Brown represented the village of Piketon, which enforced substantial liquidated damages for late project completion of a public road construction contract.

Contract Law Case Studies Contract law is made up of a variety of regulations and laws enacted to enforce promises made under certain conditions. A contract is a legally binding agreement which enforces the obligations of each party, requiring them to honour any promises made to another party or parties under certain conditions.

A short course on Construction Contract Law will be presented at the Chair in Construction Engineering and Management at the Construction guarantees: recent case studies. Charl Hugo** 14h General principles of insurance law relevant to construction risks.

Charl Hugo** 15h Tea/coffee. the law of contract and tort, to a particular commercial activity, the procuring of construction Feasibility studies may be required, usually involving a CONSTRUCTION LAW – BASIC PRINCIPLES Peter Aeberli RIBA, ARIAS, ACE, FCIArb, Barrister.

Construction contract law case studies
Rated 3/5 based on 90 review